Contributor - Europe

Cathy Buyck

Europe’s airlines increasingly have expressed worry that environmental regulations and their resulting costs will hinder the sector’s competitiveness and, ultimately, its decarbonization efforts.
Their concerns stem largely from elements of the European Green Deal, under which the European Commission has actively developed policies in the areas of energy, transport, and taxation&nbsp;with the objective of achieving climate neutrality for the European Union (EU) by 2050.&nbsp;Among its arsenal of initiatives, the “Fit for 55” package consists of a set of legislative proposals designed to curb net carbon dioxide emissions by at least 55 percent by 2030 compared with the levels recorded in 1990.
On paper, Europe’s aviation sector supports the EU's ambitious blueprint for sustainable growth and in 2021 mapped its own sustainability initiative, Destination 2050, which will see all flights within and departing the “EU+”—the 27 EU states, UK, and the European Free Trade Association countries—realizing net zero carbon dioxide (CO2) emissions by 2050. But many industry leaders question what they consider the one-sided approach regulators have taken toward achieving the goal.
A study conducted by consultants SEO Amsterdam Economics and the Royal Netherlands Aerospace Centre, released in March, calculated that the European aviation industry faces €820 billion in “premium” expenditures—or spending exclusively on sustainability—to achieve net-zero emissions by 2050. That comes on top of the €1.1 trillion in “business as usual” expenditures over the 32-year period from 2018 to 2050 considered in the Price of Net Zero study. “Business as usual expenditures alone will not generate on-time decarbonization,” the researchers noted.&nbsp; Expenditures involve investments in assets such as new aircraft and infrastructure as well as costs of developing alternative aviation fuels—including drop-in sustainable aviation fuel (SAF), hydrogen, and electricity—and technologies aimed at removing carbon from the atmosphere to achieve “negative emissions.”
Total expenditures to yield on-time net zero amount to €1.9 trillion, or €59 billion per year.&nbsp; Of the total, €820 billion will go towards new aircraft and fleet renewal, representing the largest expenditure at 43 percent.&nbsp; With a projected cost of €751 billion over the 32-year period, sustainable aviation fuels stand as the second largest expenditure, accounting for a 40 percent share, while €152 billion (19 percent) will go toward carbon pricing and economic measures, including emission trading and negative emission technologies.
“There is a new currency in town, CO2,” remarked Lufthansa Group CEO Carsten Spohr, speaking during the recent A4E Summit in Brussels. He criticized European policymakers’ lackluster approach toward incentives to increase production and the consumption of SAF. “We see [SAF] blending mandates for a product that does not exist,” he lamented. “There is global competition for green investments. Europe has to be careful; we might lose the [clean energy] race,” he said, warning that the U.S. Inflation Reduction Act (IRA) will drive SAF investments to the US. The IRA earmarks $370 billion in federal funds to assure the U.S. remains a global leader in clean energy technology, manufacturing, and innovation.
Much to airlines’ frustration, an important contributor to achieving net zero—the long-promised reform of Europe’s fragmented airspace—has shown little sign of progress. “The airspace reform is a net-zero priority. It’s been debated for over 20 years, it’s the quickest, least-expensive way to reduce emissions today,” remarked EasyJet chief executive Johan Lundgren, who described the Single European Sky (SES) discussions as “exhausting.”&nbsp; According to the European commissioner for transport Adina-Iona Valean, implementing the SES reform proposals would ensure “CO2 savings of around 10 percent through more fuel-efficient routes.”&nbsp;
<h5>Fall in demand</h5>
Achieving net zero comes with substantial costs, but some of the regulations proposed by the EU under its Green Deal objectives also will negatively affect the continent’s airlines and airports.
According to a research report commissioned by the European Parliament's transport committee, implementing the Fit for 55 measures for the aviation sector would lead to a 10 percent decline in demand for flights within the European Economic Area (EEA) and a 1.4 percent reduction in demand for flights beyond the EEA, provided consumers bear that the entire cost increase.
The researchers pointed out that the reduction in demand would disproportionally affect EU carriers, at least until regulators implement comparable policies in other regions. They also noted that decarbonization policies with an EU scope could affect the competitiveness of EU airports through the “hub-switching effect.” Specifically, they predict a 2.7 percent decrease in the number of passengers traveling to non-EEA destinations, either directly or through an EEA hub, by 2030. Additionally, the number of intercontinental passengers traveling through non-EEA hubs would rise by 1.9 percent.
The study did not consider measures to proactively reduce demand to curb CO2 growth.&nbsp;For Valean, the demand management or limitations measures increasingly contemplated across the region represent “some worrying trends.”
“I, myself, do not see flight bans or caps as a viable option,” she added. “They will only serve to restrict citizens' right to free movement, damage regional connectivity, and hamper aviation's ability to invest in its decarbonization.”

News about commercial airlines, including regulations, aircraft orders, safety, acquisitions, and mergers.

European Aviation Faces a €820 billion Tab to Reach Net Zero 

Europe’s airlines urge more incentives to help shoulder the cost of investments necessary to reach net zero by 2050.  

2024 Corporate Aviation Leadership Summit

Hanneke Weitering

News and developments about airplanes, helicopters and unmanned air vehicles used in all varieties of operations, including airlines, military, business, commercial, general aviation and private.

News and issues regarding all manner of civil and military rotorcraft and their powerplants, including helicopters, tilt rotors and unmanned air vehicles.

Archer plans demo flight at 2025 World Expo in Osaka

JAL/Sumitomo Subsidiary Soracle To Operate Archer’s eVTOL in Japan

Charles Alcock

New developments at airports including regulations and noise issues; legal disputes; openings, acquisitions and mergers.

Britain's new government is under pressure to invest in public infrastructure

How Regional Air Mobility Could Boost the UK's Strained Transport Network

News about environmental issues relating to aircraft operations, including noise issues, emissisions, and regulations. See Fuel for biofuel.

Danish charter and scheduled operator could buy up to 15 of the electric seaplanes

Nordic Seaplanes Signs for Elfly's Noemi Electric Amphibious Aircraft

Odys' blown-wing design is being developed for both uncrewed freighter and piloted airliner roles

Fiji Airways Plans To Connect Pacific Islands with Laila VTOL

Scotland-based regional airline aims to achieve zero carbon emissions

Loganair and Heart Team To Decarbonize UK Domestic Flights

UK green start-up airline wants to operate domestic services with zero carbon emissions

Ecojet Plans To Operate Arc Aerosystems' Linx P9 Hybrid Helicopter

News and issues relating to international air transport and cargo carriers, national airlines and regional airlines, including aircraft, engines, personnel, acquisitions, accidents, safety, security and training.

The Boeing electronic flight bag solution will support the low-cost carrier’s 737NG and Max fleet

Ryanair to Use Jeppesen FliteDeck Pro 5.0 EFB 

News and developments about aircraft engines, including turbofan, turboprop, turboshaft and piston.

Paris Air Show 2023

More In Airlines