Charles Alcock is managing editor of the AIN Media Group, having rejoined the company in 2019. He has been an aviation journalist since 1986, and previously worked for AIN from 1990 to 2017, most recently as editor-in-chief. His main focus is on covering new aviation technology and business models, as well as international news.
Having been raised in the London area, Alcock studied at the University of Manchester in the UK and earned an honors degree in Politics and Modern History. He speaks English and French, and some German.

Managing Editor

Charles Alcock

A new U.S. Senate report on safety oversight issues relating to the recertification of the grounded Boeing 737 Max airliner has issued strong criticism of both the FAA and the manufacturer. Among the main conclusions from the Commerce Committee report published late on Friday is that Boeing “inappropriately influenced” FAA pilots conducting human factor simulation testing of flight crew reaction times to a failure in the Maneuvering Characteristics Augmentation System (MCAS) identified as a key factor in the two fatal accidents that led to the grounding of the aircraft.

 


Boeing did not respond directly to the allegation raised in a report titled Aviation Safety Oversight. In a written statement, the company said, “We take seriously the committee’s findings and we continue to review the report in full.”

 


The main focus of the report is on allegations first raised by whistleblowers that multiple aspects of the FAA’s role in the re-certification process were “insufficient” and “improper.”

 


“The investigation revealed that these trends were often accompanied by retaliation against those who report safety violations and a lack of effective oversight, resulting in a failed FAA safety management culture,” the committee concluded in the report’s executive summary.

 


Apart from the allegation that Boeing exerted undue influence on recertification testing, the report issued five main conclusions. It found that FAA senior managers have not been held accountable for their failure to deliver adequate flight standards training and that the agency “continues to retaliate against whistleblowers instead of welcoming their disclosures in the interests of safety.”

 


The committee, chaired by Senator Roger Wicker (R-Mississippi), also alleged that the FAA allowed Southwest Airlines to continue operating 88 aircraft “in an unknown airworthiness condition” between 2013 and 2017. The report said that the lives of millions of passengers had been put at risk due in the process.

 


However, it is unclear why the committee included the complaint about Southwest Airlines in its report about safety oversight of the Max, which was only certified in March 2017. The report does not specify exactly which aircraft types the committee alleges were improperly operated but Southwest solely operates Boeing 737s.

 


Chairman Wicker specifically complained that the Department of Transportation Office of General Counsel failed to produce relevant documents. The <a href="https://www.commerce.senate.gov/services/files/FFDA35FA-0442-465D-AC63-5634D9D3CEF6">report also claimed</a> that FAA senior leaders might have obstructed a review of the Max accidents conducted by the department’s Office of Inspector General.

 


The committee said that FAA has responded to fewer than half of the 30 specific requests for information. It added that the agency has failed to make all requested employees available for interview. From the interviews conducted with FAA staff, the report highlighted&nbsp;“inconsistencies, contradictions and in one case possible lack of candor.”

 


The committee said that it is still reviewing information received from additional whistleblowers and pressing the FAA for all requested information.

 


The agency lifted the grounding of the U.S.-registered 737 Max fleet on <a href="https://www.ainonline.com/aviation-news/air-transport/2020-11-18/faa-lifts-grounding-order-boeing-737-max">November 18</a>, and its Brazilian counterpart followed suit a few days later. However, EASA and Transport Canada are taking longer to review proposed airworthiness directives, which are expected to be issued in January.

 


[This report was updated on December 21 to correct a reference to the Senate committee's complaint about FAA oversight of Southwest Airlines]

News about significant aircraft accidents and information from accident reports.

Senate Report Blasts FAA and Boeing Over Max Recertification

The Senate report alleges that Boeing pressured FAA test pilots in human factors evaluation of the 737 Max's Maneuvering Characteristics Augmentation.

2024 Corporate Aviation Leadership Summit

AmyWilder

News and issues concerning general aviation, specifically airplanes and helicopters powered by piston and alternative engines (i.e., non-turbine powered aircraft). Subjects include aircraft, engines, personnel, acquisitions, accidents, safety, security and training.

Wet runway surface, short available landing space may be factors

Cessna Citation CJ1+ Overruns Runway in Brazil, Killing Pilot

News and issues regarding all manner of civil and military rotorcraft and their powerplants, including helicopters, tilt rotors and unmanned air vehicles.

News and information on safety procedures and concerns.

News and issues relating to business, corporate and private aviation, primarily regarding turbine-engine-powered airplanes and helicopters. Subjects include aircraft, engines, maintenance, operations, personnel, acquisitions, accidents, safety, security, and training.

Family of passenger killed has filed a lawsuit seeking damages from manufacturer Leonardo

UK Inquest To Assess Causes of AW169 Fatal Accident 

Neelam Mathews

Essential news and analysis on the defense aerospace business. Your trusted source for new and ongoing programs and requirements in military aircraft (manned and unmanned), engines, avionics, weapons and associated systems, including ground-based air defense.

More In Accidents

Cessna Citation CJ1+ Overruns Runway in Brazil, Killing Pilot

Wet runway surface, short available landing space may be factors

UK Inquest To Assess Causes of AW169 Fatal Accident

Family of passenger killed has filed a lawsuit seeking damages from manufacturer Leonardo

Investigators Probe Coast Guard Dhruv Helicopter Crash

Hindustan Aeronautics is working on type certification of civil variant of rotorcraft

Civil Drone Causes Midair Collision with Super Scooper

Damage to a wing leading edge grounded the CL-415 water bomber

Business Jet Accident Fatalities Drop Nearly 35% in 2024

Non-U.S. turboprop accidents stayed unchanged but fatalities increased

Business Aircraft Accident Reports: January 2025

Preliminary and final accident reports, January 2025

Cheyenne Crash in Brazil Kills All Onboard, Injures 17

Business owner, family members, and colleague were onboard

NTSB Prelim Points To Distraction in Bizjet Collision

Hawker crew did not respond to controller’s orders

AIN Products

SUBSCRIPTIONS

RESOURCES

ABOUT AIN